Abstracts - Lincoln 2023 - University of Lincoln
SVPCA Conference
Poster
3D geometric morphometrics on Carboniferous Polygnathus conodonts suggests temporal and ontogenetic differences rather than two coexisting genera
 
Félix Nesme
 
1
Institut des Sciences de l’Évolution de Montpellier
 
2
Laboratoire de Biométrie et Biologie Évolutive
The diversified conodont genus Polygnathus has been proposed to be split into Polygnathus sensu stricto, and several new genera. Among them, Neopolygnathus, described from the Late Devonian / Early Carboniferous, differs from Polygnathus s.s. only by the presence of a depression on its aboral face posterior to the basal cavity.

The morphological variation of Polygnathus s.l. has been quantified using 3D geometric morphometrics in ten levels from the Puech de la Suque section (France) where Neopolygnathus cooccurs with Polygnathus s.s.. Four successive groups of levels sharing similar patterns of morphological variation have been identified. Within these groups, if size-related variation is accounted for, the two proposed genera Neopolygnathus and Polygnathus s.s. do not differ significantly in shape. The degree of expression of the aboral depression varies as a continuous and coherent gradient within each group. The frequency of conodonts with well-expressed depression however varies between the four groups, due to differences in the shape of the platform and in ontogenetic growth patterns. 


The genus Neopolygnathus is therefore not supported by the 3D morphometric analysis. The conodont elements being tooth-like structures involved in occlusion, the functional consequences of the morphological differences observed along the section requires further investigation.

Platform presentation
A case study investigating varying muscle input parameters on finite element models of the tenrec mandible
 
Kacper Starczewski
 
1
Bristol Palaeobiology Research Group, School of Earth Sciences, University of Bristol, Bristol BS8 1RJ, UK.
 
2
Department of Engineering, University of Hull, Cottingham Road, Hull HU6 7RX, UK.
 
3
Department of Ecology and Evolutionary, Biology, Brown University, Providence, Rhode Island, USA.
Biomechanical modelling is a powerful tool for inferring functional
performance in extinct animals and higher-level inferences such as
macroevolution. Model accuracy is dictated by muscle input parameters such
as fibre length and muscle volume. In fossils, muscle reconstructions are
informed by osteological features in fossils and anatomical data from related
extant species, which can yield errors in reconstructions and higher-level
inferences. In this study, we assess how varying muscle input
parameters influence finite element (FE) model results. We created a FEmodel from CT data of a Hemicentetes semispinosus (lowland-streaked tenrec)
mandible, with adductor muscle forces calculated from muscle mass and fibre
length measured via dissection. We compared the results of this model to FEmodels created by varying muscle input parameters estimated via two
modelling techniques conventionally used on fossil animals – muscle volume
sculpture and the dry skull method. We also assessed the impact of changing
fibre length on stress and strain outputs. Quantitative results varied in the
degree of accuracy compared to the specimen-specific models,
but predominantly failed to capture absolute magnitudes. However, most
qualitative differences in bone stress distribution and relative magnitudes
across the models are retained. This emphasises the importance of muscle
property datasets and validation studies.
A methodology for Species Distribution Modelling in Dinosaurs
 
Max Stockdale
 
1
University of Bristol
Species Distribution Modelling is a versatile and robust tool for estimating the geographic range of organisms using environmental variables. It relies upon the assumption that the greatest concentration of species occurrences will be at the location where the environment is most optimal. This presents challenges to palaeontologists, because fossil data is expected to concentrate in places where the preservation and sampling potential is highest. Therefore, fossil data cannot be expected to satisfy the assumptions of species distribution models. This presentation proposes an alternative methodology for species distribution modelling with fossil organisms. This altnerative methodology yeilds contrasting results to conventional approaches. It also suggests that systematic biases are introduced when traditional methods are used to model the geographic distribution of fossil organisms.
Lightining Talk
A new anklyosaurian osteoderm from the Middle–Late Jurassic Oxford Clay Formation, UK
 
Jordan Bestwick
 
1
Nottingham Natural History Museum
 
2
Natural History Museum, London

Ankylosaurs are a characteristic group of dinosaurs recognised by their extensive covering of dermal armour (osteoderms) across their bodies. The Middle–Late Jurassic (Bathonian–Oxfordian) Oxford Clay Formation, UK, contains among the earliest known ankylosaur material, including osteoderms assigned to Sarcolestes and a few currently unidentified species. The formation is thus important for understanding early ankylosaur evolution. Here, we describe an osteoderm from the Oxford Clay of Peterborough that exhibits a different morphology to other osteoderms from this formation. The specimen, although incomplete along its transverse axis, measures 43 mm across its anteroposterior axis with a spine length of 52 mm. The osteoderm is subrectangular with a concave ventral surface and a low-lying spine on its dorsal surface that slightly extends beyond the posterior margin of the specimen base. This morphology is superficially more similar to the thoracic osteoderms of more derived Cretaceous ankylosaurs from North America (e.g. Borealopelta, Edmontonia), than to Oxford Clay specimens and other contemporaneous Jurassic ankylosaurs (e.g. Tianchisaurus). Although its isolated nature prevents reliable identification of the taxon and body part to which it belonged, the osteoderm nevertheless indicates a larger morphological diversity in the body armour of the earliest ankylosaurs than currently appreciated.

Platform presentation
A new leptopleuronine procolophonid from the Late Triassic of southwest England
 
Richard Butler
 
1
University of Birmingham
 
2
Natural History Museum, London
 
3
University of Oxford
 
4
University of Cambridge
 
5
National Museums Scotland

The fissure fill localities of southwest England and South Wales are well-known for preserving rich assemblages of predominantly small-bodied Late Triassic to Early Jurassic tetrapods, but many aspects of these assemblages remain contentious. The fissures have been hypothesized by some workers to have formed on an archipelago, with island effects invoked to explain aspects of the assemblages such as the abundance of small-bodied species. Procolophonids were a successful group of Triassic parareptiles, best known from Early to early Late Triassic assemblages, but are poorly known from the fissure fills. Here, we describe new procolophonid specimens from the Cromhall fissure that represent at least six individuals of different sizes, with much of the skeleton represented including well-preserved skull material. The Cromhall procolophonid shows strong similarities to Late Triassic procolophonids from Scotland, Brazil and North America, but both autapomorphies and a unique character combination demonstrate that it represents a new species. Phylogenetic analysis places the Cromhall taxon in a derived clade within Leptopleuroninae, together with Leptopleuron, Hypsognathus and Soturnia. The largest specimens of the Cromhall taxon demonstrate a body size that is similar to Leptopleuron and Hypsognathus, supporting other recent work questioning the insular dwarfism hypothesis for the fissure fill assemblages.

Poster
A new Middle Triassic Tanzanian dicynodont species associated with strongly curved claws
 
Hady George
 
1
University of Edinburgh
 
2
University of Bristol
 
3
University of Reading
 
4
Museo Argentino de Ciencias Naturales
 
5
Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas
 
6
University of Dodoma

The Manda Beds of Tanzania have produced a diverse assemblage of Middle Triassic tetrapods including 6 dicynodont taxa. Recent examination of a death assemblage of multiple dicynodont species collected in 1963 by Charig and Cox and reposited in the Natural History Museum, London has identified a cranium and mandible clearly belonging to a single individual which is substantially different to the other Tanzanian dicynodonts. The presence of hypertrophied tusks, a squared off premaxilla tip, a triangular skull in dorsal view, and the lack of a ridge along the nasals indicate this individual has more similarities with the South American Dinodontosaurus than other taxa. However, it also has several unique features such as a bulbous posterior ridge on the premaxilla, incompletely fused splenials, and an anteroposteriorly short palatal area. This suggests this individual belongs to a novel taxon, and a phylogenetic analysis accompanied with statistical tests further support this hypothesis. Among the associated postcranial elements are strongly curved unguals never before reported in dicynodonts. If these unguals belong to the same taxon as the skull, the unique suite of adaptations would have facilitated a mode of foraging different to that of contemporary dicynodont taxa, allowing them to occupy separate ecological roles.

Platform presentation
Advances in Understanding Plesiosaur Locomotion: Insights from a Free-Swimming Robot
 
Luke Muscott
 
1
Imperial College London

Plesiosaurs employed a distinctive four-flipper swimming method that granted them remarkable advantages in swimming speed and endurance. Previous investigations primarily focused on elucidating the mechanisms and benefits of this propulsion method using flume tank experiments. However, these experiments had notable limitations, such as the absence of rotational movement around the articular socket, and the exclusion of the plesiosaur body, neck, head, and tail.


In this study, we present recent developments that have significantly advanced our understanding of plesiosaur locomotion. Specifically, we have successfully developed a free-swimming plesiosaur robot that accurately replicates the body morphology and flipper kinematics of these extinct creatures. This innovative robot serves as a valuable experimental tool, allowing us to investigate various flipper shapes, kinematics, and the influence of head, neck, and tail morphologies.


Our novel approach, employing an accurate plesiosaur robot as a test platform, provides unprecedented insights into the evolutionary adaptations and locomotor capabilities of these marine reptiles. By gaining a deeper understanding of the hydrodynamics of plesiosaur swimming, we can acquire valuable knowledge applicable to both biological and engineering contexts. This knowledge holds great potential for advancements in underwater robotics and the development of biomimetic design principles.

Bird clades with less complex appendicular skeletons tend to be more diverse
 
Andrew Brinkworth
 
1
University of Bath
 
2
University of Lincoln
 
3
Nanjing Institute of Geology and Paleontology
 
4
University College London

Species richness is unevenly distributed across clades of all taxonomic ranks. Based on a body of theoretical work, and our own empirical findings, we propose that uneven species richness may be partially determined by varying morphological complexity between groups. While it is impossible to measure complexity directly, it is possible to derive proxies based on the morphology of particular structures. Specifically, the number of parts comprising a structure, their relative differentiation from one another, and the relative disorder of their arrangement, can be used to derive useful proxies. In this work, we derived an index of complexity for 983 extant species of bird, based on serial differentiation of bones in the limb skeleton. We showed that the mean complexity exhibited by extant bird clades correlates negatively with their species richness. Further, we showed that mean complexity correlates negatively with the ecological niche diversity for each clade. This simple proxy for ecological specialisation is also correlates positively with clade species richness. We suggest that these findings demonstrate complexity-mediated ecological constraint, which in turn limits the ability of clades to diversify. 

Can limb muscle masses be predicted from skeletal morphologies? A case study using extant archosaurs.
 
Matthew Dempsey
 
1
University of Liverpool
 
2
Natural History Museum UK
Understanding musculoskeletal properties is essential to the study of tetrapod locomotion, the evolution of which underpins key morphological radiations across deep time. However, due to the lack of soft tissue preservation in most fossils, muscle reconstruction is often subjective, with different methods producing varying results. By collating data from dissections and CT-based models, we established a workflow for estimating limb muscle properties across extinct archosaurs through correlations between muscle masses and skeletal surface areas in extant taxa. Rather than focusing on specific attachment areas and intrinsically variable muscle divisions, we combined muscles into major functional groups, and sought correlations with whole-bone external surface areas. Our results suggest strong relationships between multiple muscle group masses and whole-bone surface areas, particularly in the triceps femoris (thigh flexors and knee extensors) and gastrocnemii (knee flexors and ankle extensors). Our results also show nuanced allometric differences between different limb muscle groups, which suggests that caution should be exercised when attempting to estimate muscle masses in any given fossil taxon from a single extant analogue. These relationships provide a quantitative baseline from which muscle mass properties can be predicted more broadly across Archosauria, further illuminating the anatomical changes associated with major functional innovations.
Cementochronology reveals the evolution of life history amongst the earliest mammals
 
Elis Newham
 
1
Queen Mary University of London
 
2
Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität
 
3
University of Bristol
 
4
Natural History Museum London
 
5
University of Helsinki
 
6
Geological Survey of Finland

The Jurassic radiation of crown mammals has been linked to the acquisition of key physiological innovations, including the evolution of determinate patterns of rapid juvenile growth truncated at sexual maturity. These patterns are intrinsically related to the evolution of mammals’ endothermic physiology, the timing and mechanisms of which remain under considerable debate. We use synchrotron X-ray tomographic imaging of annual growth increments in the dental cementum of Early-to-Late Jurassic mammaliaforms (mammals and their closest ancestors) to map the origin and evolution of mammalian determinate growth. Non-mammalian mammaliaforms exhibited slow growth-rates with relatively little change through life. Early crown mammals developed significantly faster juvenile growth-rates that reduced at the attainment of sexual maturity, showing distinct contrasts in structure between juvenile and adult cementum. All fossils studied retained lower growth-rates, longer estimated maximum lifespans, and delayed sexual maturity relative to comparably sized extant mammals. Estimation of basal-metabolic-rates (BMRs) using lifespan also suggests that non-mammalian mammaliaforms retained low BMRs, while some fossil crown mammals had BMRs approaching the lowest values of extant mammals. These patterns suggest that the mammalian determinate growth strategy first evolved amongst early crown mammals during the mid-Jurassic mammalian adaptive radiation, although growth remained slower than in extant mammals.

Poster
Claws - a new tool for understanding the terrestrial ecology of pterosaurs?
 
Stella A. Ludwig
 
1
University of Portsmouth, School of the Environment, Geography and Geosciences, Portsmouth PO1 2 QL, UK
 
2
University of Leicester, Department of Museum Studies, Leicester LE1 7RF, UK

Pterosaurs were a group of flying archosauromorph reptiles that appeared in the Late Triassic and became extinct at the end of the Cretaceous. While there have been numerous examinations of pterosaur flight capabilities, their modes of terrestrial locomotion remain poorly constrained. In this study, the terrestrial ecology of pterosaurs is reviewed using a novel methodological approach utilising ungual and claw sheath morphometrics.


Amniote claws are complex structures that are intimately connected to lifestyle and locomotory habits, and therefore can, by extension, yield intriguing data on ecology and function. Claw morphology presents an understudied yet promising model system for the study of ecology in extinct amniotes through comparisons with the ecomorphospace occupied by extant taxa.


To facilitate a comprehensive ecomorphospace comparison, a dataset of pterosaur claw photographs encompassing a large taxonomic diversity has been compiled. This data has revealed a hitherto unrecorded morphological diversity in pterosaur manual and pedal unguals, as well as variable relationships between ungual and claw sheath morphologies in different taxa. These valuable new insights further our understanding of pterosaur ecology and expand our knowledge of the morphological diversity present in amniote claws as a whole.

Platform presentation
Cranial kinesis mechanics and feeding ecology among birds
 
Amber Wagstaffe
 
1
University of Hull
 
2
American Museum of Natural History
 
3
University of Illinois
 
4
University of Sheffield

Cranial kinesis in birds allows the rotation of the upper beak relative to the skull via displacement of the palate. This important mechanism tends to be overlooked in feeding studies, but the cranial kinetic system may provide new insights into the form-function relationships between bird skulls and their ecology. 


Using a simple 2D four-bar linkage model, we modelled cranial kinesis using lateral images of 308 extant bird species. Kinematic Transmission (KT) and gape measurements were compared with feeding categories. We also compared these metrics with link lengths and considered these results in the context of four-bar biological systems as a whole.  


Although KT did not demonstrate strong relationships with feeding ecology, the addition of the beak to the 4-bar system permits significant separation of dietary groups by accommodating gape differences within the models. Additionally, we find that body size appears to constrain the feeding method employed by birds. Analysis of link lengths revealed that the output link (beak depth) is more strongly correlated with KT than the input (quadrate). This is despite the fact that within birds, the output link is not the shortest link, which was the trait previously believed to drive mechanical sensitivity in other biological four-bar systems.  

Poster
Duplicating a dead horse: recreating the lost Crystal Palace Palaeotherium magnum
 
Mark Witton
 
1
University of Portsmouth
 
2
Natural History Museum, Friends of Crystal Palace Dinosaurs

Eight of the original 37 Crystal Palace Dinosaurs sculptures have vanished in the last 170 years. Most of these constitute mammal reconstructions from the “Tertiary Island” and are poorly documented, frustrating efforts to understand their morphology and the circumstances surrounding their disappearances. An exception is the sculpture of the Eocene equoid Palaeotherium magnum, which was photographed and illustrated in relative detail before it was lost six decades ago. These records have allowed a replica P. magnum to be created in the first effort at replacing a lost Crystal Palace “Dinosaur” since 2003. Initiated by the Friends of Crystal Palace Dinosaurs charity, the replica was funded through public contributions and a grant from the Crystal Palace Park Trust, and was sculpted by Robert Nicholls in his Bristol studio. We estimate that the original P. magnum model exceeded 2 m in length and, instead of the tapir-like form suggested by leading Victorian scholars, its anatomy was primarily informed by African elephant species. Recreated in durable fibreglass, the replica was unveiled alongside the two surviving Crystal Palace palaeothere sculptures in June 2023. Future restorative work includes plans to recreate another lost palaeothere component, the original head of the sitting “Palaeotherium minus”.

Platform presentation
Elucidating the ecological and life history drivers of Galloanserae skull evolution using high density 3D geometric morphometrics
 
Eloise Hunt
 
1
Natural History Museum London
 
2
Imperial College London
 
3
University College London
 
4
University of Cambridge
 
5
University of Birmingham
Our research aims to elucidate the drivers of Galloanserae (ducks, chickens, and relatives) skull evolution. We created and analysed a comprehensive 3D dataset of skull morphology for >230 species, including key extinct lineages, to uncover their morphological variation and quantify the factors driving this disparity. Extant Galloanserae only represent a fraction of the remarkable morphological and ecological diversity they attained over ~67 million years of evolution. We tested the hypothesis that extinct Galloanserae exhibit distinct cranial forms unrepresented in extant taxa. Additionally, we isolated the relative influences of ecological and life history traits on skull shape variation and evolutionary rates. Principal Component Analysis (PCA) revealed that extinct clades greatly expand the breadth of Galloanserae morphospace occupation beyond what could be inferred from extant taxa alone. Analyses show significant relationships between skull shape and ecology (P = 0.039), habitat density (P = 0.001), and migration (P = 0.0016). Rate analyses demonstrate heterogenous rates of evolution for different character states within habitat density, migration, diet, and developmental mode. Our results indicate that ecology, habitat density, migration, and diet are key factors influencing the skull evolution of Galloanserae and highlight the importance of fossils to inform estimates of phenotypic disparity.
European pouches weigh: new insights on the evolutionary history of early Cenozoic Laurasian ‘opossum-like’ marsupials
 
Killian Gernelle
 
1
ISEM (Institut Sciences Evolution - Montpellier), Université de Montpellier
 
2
CR2P (Centre de Recherche en Paléontologie), Muséum National Histoire Naturelle
Peradectidae and Herpetotheriidae are mostly Laurasian, superficially ‘opossum-like’ metatherians (marsupials and related fossils) known by their generalist dentition and frequently regarded as arboreal stem-metatherians and terrestrial stem-marsupials, respectively. Uncovering the origins of these families thus represents a milestone to address key questions regarding the evolutionary history of the whole Metatheria. A systematic revision of Early Eocene European Peradectes integrates new dental rows together with an analysis of dental polymorphisms. It allows us to define the oldest European Peradectes species and to further show that a unique dispersal event towards Europe occurred during the evolutionary history of peradectids. We also report the first metatherian from the Paleocene of Europe and oldest undisputed herpetotheriid. It notably reveals the simultaneous independent acquisition of the same stylar cusp features on upper molars in the European Eocene species of the coeval families. Finally, we carried out a cladistic analysis at the metatherian level based on a majority of newly defined dental characters. For the first time, a Laurasian monophyletic group Peradectidae including all Paleocene-Eocene species is recovered. Peradectidae turn out to be part of a robust and resolved unnamed clade probably emerging consecutive to the K-Pg boundary and encompassing ‘Notometatheria’ (all South American and Australian metatherians plus herpetotheriids).
Evolutionary ratchet drives long-term trend despite fluctuating climatic driver
 
Adrian Lister
 
1
Natural History Museum
 
2
Department of Geosciences and Geography, University of Helsinki
We present new data on proboscidean dental evolution in East Africa over the past 26 million years, tracking temporal patterns of morphological change in relation to proxy evidence of diet, vegetation and climate (aridity). Strongly directional trends in molar crown height (hypsodonty), enamel thickness, and the number of enamel lamellae in the molar, occur in parallel across several elephant genera. We partition traits by selective agent, showing that the acquisition of high-crowned, multi-lamellar molars was primarily a response to an increase in open, arid environments with high dust accumulation (quantified in offshore cores), whereas enamel folding was more associated with the amount of grass in the diet (quantified via dental mesowear). We further show that long-term trends in these features proceeded in a ratchet-like mode, alternating between directional change at times of high selective pressure and stasis (not evolutionary reversal) when the selective regime reversed. In this way a strongly directional trend can accumulate with each climatic pulse.  This pattern provides an explanation for morphology adapted to more extreme conditions than current usage (Liem’s Paradox), if the selective force is currently below its former maximum.
External Morphology or Internal Anatomy – Assessing Determinants of Mandibular Mass Distribution
 
Adrian Maurice O Driscoll
 
1
Hull York Medical School, University of York
 
2
Department of Musculoskeletal & Ageing Science, Institute of Life Course & Medical Sciences, University of Liverpool
 
3
Department of Archaeology, University of York

Mammals have a distinctive masticatory system, and the distribution of bone in the mandible varies within and between species due to differences in form and function and remodelling in response to mechanical loading. Mass distribution and its functional significance have been well studied in mammalian limbs and locomotory biomechanics, but mandibles and mastication have largely been ignored. I investigated the degree to which material density variation influences centre of mass (CoM) to better understand the determinants of mandibular mass distribution and tested five estimation methods for agreement against an established standard. I estimated CoM for an interspecific sample of 40-adult-specimens (Orders Artiodactyla, Perissodactyla, Proboscidea) and an ontogenetic series of 15-individuals (Diceros bicornis), using analogue and CT-based methods. Mass distribution data estimated with, and without, specification of material density does not significantly differ. CoM may be accurately estimated using surface scans in adult specimens, and in the ontogenetic case, simple linear measurements. That CoM can be reliably approximated from external form alone across a functionally diverse group of taxa implies remodelling of the internal architecture of the mandible does not meaningfully contribute to mass distribution. The tested methods exhibit high agreement, allowing datasets to be composed using a variety of approaches.

Other abstracts
Factors determining persistent asymmetry and egg shape in birds: A hypothesis
 
D Charles Deeming
 
1
School of Life and Environmental Sciences, University of Lincoln, Lincoln, LN6 7DL, UK

The various shapes of birds’ eggs have fascinated scientists for many years. It is now possible to mathematically describe shape accurately, allowing exploration of the physical and ecological factors driving evolution of egg shape. However, there has been relatively little consideration of: 1) how egg shape is established in the oviduct, or 2) how eggs retain their shape, even without an external calcitic layer. Here I postulate a hypothesis that answers these questions. The hypothesis suggests that, as the egg mass (i.e., yolk and albumen) moves from the magnum into the isthmus, it is squeezed by the physical restriction imposed by the isthmus lumen and cannot easily move into the isthmus. As the leading edge of the egg mass enters the isthmus, the egg mass in the distal magnum is forced to bulge outwards, resulting in an asymmetrical shape. The various egg shapes observed in birds are hence, produced by the interaction between the size of the egg mass relative to female body mass, and the degree of the restriction of the isthmus. Thus, a large egg mass, i.e., relative to female body mass, entering a narrow isthmus will produce a pointed egg shape. If the egg mass is relatively small, and the isthmus lumen wide, more of the egg mass could enter the isthmus and the degree of asymmetry is reduced. It is further proposed that egg shape is fixed by the formation of the shell membranes in the isthmus because the constituent protein fibres permanently stick together as they are deposited in the isthmus.  The implications of the hypothesis for the diversity of egg shapes in birds (and reptiles), and for the deposition and characteristics of the calcitic egg, are wide-ranging.

Lightining Talk
Innovations in Hindlimb Shape Throughout Theropod Phylogeny Demonstrated Using Mosimann Variables
 
Shane Wheatley
 
1
University of Lincoln
Theropod hindlimb evolution has been subject to extensive study, primarily describing the locomotory properties of the hindlimbs. Despite this, the shape evolution of the hindlimbs throughout theropod phylogeny is understudied. The origin of key traits, such as flight and the enlarged second pedal unguals, are due to morphological changes over time in the hindlimbs and are poorly understood. Mosimann variables are a powerful tool in extracting morphological variation from linear measurements, accounting for size, which would normally confound interpretations of morphology. These variables can be used in conjunction with other shape methods to quantify morphological change over phylogenetic time. 34 measurements from the femur, tibia, metatarsals, and the second pes were taken from all major clades of Therapoda, excluding neognaths. When taken as a single unit, femur and tibia shape separate based on size. However, tibia shape instead separates into two broad, distinct groups, Paraves and non-paravian theropods.  Lower limb shape variation appears to be independent of size, with Dromaeosauridae separating due to an enlarged second claw, and Therizinosauridae separating based on a wide, squat lower limb. These results indicate significant shape changes in the hindlimb throughout theropod phylogeny and highlights the need for further work in the aforementioned clades.
Poster
Interpretation of fossil embryos requires reasonable assessment of developmental age
 
D Charles Deeming
 
1
School of Life and Environmental Sciences, University of Lincoln, Lincoln, LN6 7DL, UK

Dinosaur embryos cause a lot of excitement in the scientific literature and are widely reported in the popular press. Well-preserved, articulated oviraptorosaur embryos in eggs are usually interpreted as representing a stage of development close to hatching because of their large size and good level of skeletal ossification. Here we explore how the developmental stage of oviraptorosaur embryos can be estimated, rather than assumed. Using quantitative methods in comparison with modern crocodilian embryos, it was shown that articulated oviraptorosaur embryos are small relative to their egg length which suggests a stage of development equivalent to around 50%–60% of the developmental period rather than being close to hatching. Moreover, many elements of the crocodilian skeleton are well ossified at this point of development. Misunderstandings about the stage of the developmental biology of these and other well-preserved embryos hampers our understanding of the true nature of reproductive biology and development of extinct species. Palaeontologists should adopt a more conservative approach for initial interpretation of new specimens. This is important, because misunderstandings in the minds of the public about dinosaur biology are hard to counter once poorly evidenced ideas have been reported around the world.

Platform presentation
It’s all about the upstroke: allometric analysis of flight muscles in birds demonstrates that flight style is a function of variability in supracoracoideus mass
 
D. Charles Deeming
 
1
University of Lincoln

Avian flight is powered by a downstroke force generated by the pectoralis (P) muscle and an upstroke force generated by the supracoracoideus (SC) muscle. This analysis explored the allometry of flight muscles to test for isometry with body mass in birds more generally. Data for muscle masses for over 600 species, representing 28 orders, were used in phylogenetically controlled analysis of covariance to test for the effects of order on allometry of flight muscles. The pectoralis scaled isometrically with body mass, but the supracoracoideus muscle exhibited a slight but significant negative allometry. Both muscles showed significant effects of order, but this effect was greatest for the supracoracoideus. As well as wing-propelled diving birds, and hovering hummingbirds, tinamous, gamebirds, and pigeons, which exhibit burst flight, also had had a disproportionately large supracoracoideus. This is needed to generate a powerful upstroke to counter water-borne drag or gravity. Many other orders had a P:SC ratio around 10:1 but values of 20:1, recorded for raptors and owls, were associated with relatively small supracoracoideus muscle mass. Differing flight styles reflect variability in supracoracoideus mass, rather than pectoralis mass. The significance of this result will impact our understanding of how morphology impacts flight action of birds.

Poster
Locomotion in Extinct "Giant" Kangaroos: Information from Finite Element Analysis of the Astragalus
 
Christine Janis
 
1
University of Bristol

All modern kangaroos (Macropodidae) hop. It is likely that some extinct “giant “ (i.e., larger than extant species) kangaroos likely did not hop, or hopped only rarely. Extinct short-faced kangaroos (Sthenurinae) were likely bipedal striders while Protemnodon species (“giant wallabies”, closely related to modern large kangaroos, Macropodinae) were probably more quadrupedal than their extant relatives.


The astragalus, comprising part of the ankle joint, plays a key role in transmitting locomotory forces. Using Finite Element Analysis we investigated astragalar stresses during different simulated types of locomotion to see if different stress patterns could be determined among large kangaroos, extinct and extant. We varied body mass (transmitted over two legs or one, whether hopping [5x body mass], bounding quadrupedally or bipedal striding [both 2x body mass]) and the tibia/astragalus angle (900 during hopping and bounding, 1200 during striding) and compared pairs of taxa of similar body masses. Hoppers showed greater stress in striding simulations than hopping simulations; the striders performed well in both simulations but better in striding. The likely more quadrupedal Protemnodon performed poorly all simulations except bounding, where its low stresses were similar to the other kangaroos. Our results thus support prior hypotheses of alternative locomotion in extinct giant kangaroos.

On Ossirarus kierani, a curious little tetrapod from Romer’s Gap
 
Timothy Richard Smithson
 
1
University of Cambridge
 
2
Department of Life Sciences, University of Lincoln, Joseph Banks Laboratories, Green Lane, Lincoln LN6 7DL, UK

Tetrapods are rare in the early Carboniferous. Until recently, they were represented by a few disarticulated limb and girdle bones from Nova Scotia and the skeleton of Perderpes from Scotland. Discoveries in the Scottish Borders have greatly expanded our knowledge of post-Devonian tetrapods and six new taxa have been named and briefly described so far. One of these, Ossirarus kierani, represented by a single specimen from the coastal section of the Tournaisian Ballagan Formation at Burnmouth, comprises the disarticulated bones of the posterior half of the skull, the anterior portion of the axial skeleton, and parts of the pectoral girdle and forelimbs. Compared with Pederpes it is small, with an estimated skull length of 55 mm. Like Acanthostega, it has a preopercular and a lateral line system represented by pores. It shares with embolomeres, a tabular-parietal suture, an intertemporal and a long tabular horn. The gastrocentrous vertebrae resemble those of Caerorhachis and the brachial foramen pierces the humerus through the posterior edge, as in Mesanerpeton. Preliminary phylogenetic analyses place Ossirarus on the tetrapod stem-group, crownward of some – but not all – Devonian taxa. The topology of the tetrapod stem suggests that numerous lineages of Carboniferous tetrapods extended back into the Devonian.

Platform presentation
On the alleged furcula of Allosaurus
 
Michael Howgate
 
1
71 Hoppers Road, Winchmore Hill, London N21 3LP
In the early 1970's, when the dinosaur-bird link was first propounded by Professor John Ostrom, there was a problem.  Dinosaurs did not have clavicles, the precursors of the avian furcula, so therapod dinosaurs could not have been the ancestors of birds.

A flurry of activity ensued in which any suitably curved bone found associated with a theropod dinosaur was 'shoe-horned' into becoming a furcula.  Some of the first such bones were five obtusely V-shaped bones excavated from the Cleveland-Lloyd quarry between 1960 and 1964.  They were identified by Jim Madsen, in his 1976 monograph 'Allosaurus fragilis: a revised osteology', as conjoined median abdominal ribs (conjoined gastralia).  Soon however the identification was revised to furculae in line with the then current 'revolution' in dinosaur taxonomy. 

The bones are however identical in shape with the conjoined median gastralia found in many modern reptiles and have similarly chamfered articulation facets.  Thus the most parsimonious identification of 'V' and 'U' shaped bones found in theropod dinosaur skeletons is that they are median gastralia not furculae.
Ontogeny and tooth replacement in the Brazilian cynodont Brasilodon quadrangularis
 
Pamela G Gill
 
1
University of Bristol, UK
 
2
Natural History Museum London, UK
 
3
3Museo Argentino de Ciencias Naturales “Bernardino Rivadavia”, Argentina
 
4
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil
 
5
University of Helsinki, Finland
 
6
Geological Survey of Finland, Finland
Brasilodon quadrangularis is a probainognathian cynodont from the Late Triassic (Norian) of southern Brazil that is phylogenetically positioned close to Mammaliaformes. This taxon is based upon several skulls and isolated jaws, including the junior synonyms Brasilitherium riograndensis and Minicynodon maieri, from a range of ontogenetic stages. To investigate the tooth replacement pattern in Brasilodon, several specimens were micro-CT scanned. We observed that: 1) postcanines vary from five to seven functional tooth positions, with the loss of at least four anterior postcanines during ontogeny (indicating at least 11 positions during life); (2) there is more than one tooth replacement at anterior loci in juvenile forms, and the diastema enlargement is a result of the loss of incisor-like canines of juveniles and the anteriormost postcanine teeth; (3) as the middle postcanines are replaced alternately, new posterior postcanines are added; (4) larger individuals have a more disparate postcanine morphology than smaller individuals, indicating that replaced teeth are simpler than new ones. This data demonstrates Brasilodon has not acquired a diphyodont tooth replacement, which is a major apomorphy for mammaliaforms. Tooth replacement mechanisms amongst non-mammaliaform cynodonts are highly diverse, and Brasilodon indicates a unique replacement pattern among probainognathians, sharing resemblances with Sinoconodon.
Pachycormids, Palaeontologists and Pandemics : A Sea of Surface Publishing Pressure Leads to Ethical Breaches
 
Jeff Liston
 
1
Royal Tyrrell Museum of Palaeontology
 
2
University of Southampton
Pachycormids have been viewed as a marginal group of actinopterygia, substantively regarded as a curiosity with little intrinsic value, arising off the main line of teleost ancestry and thus attracting little research focus beyond descriptions of new specimens and occasionally consequent new taxa. Exceptions include Mainwaring's 1978 review and Lambers' 1992 revisions of the group. This changed midway through the 2000s, when this group were invigorated through rigorous reexamination, with particular emphasis on the suspension-feeders. The rise of research focus on these animals reflects a broader rise in the production of vertebrate palaeontologists and their being subject to the imperative to publish or perish. This means that researching in areas related to these animals has become remarkably competitive, with ethically questionable behaviour that might only have been associated with theropod dinosaurs over the last few decades. As a case study, this presentation will review some of the aspects of this transition and discuss how much it relates to the growth in palaeontologists competing over the same slice of major taxa, together with the prospects for expanding the range of research into new areas, for example behavioural, to keep ahead of or distinct from the competition.
Predictive simulations of musculoskeletal function and sit-to-stand in birds: insights for extinct vertebrate locomotion
 
*
Yuting Lin
1
 
Lars D'Hondt
3
 
Delyle Polet
1
 
Friedl De Groote
3
 
Mehran Moazen
2
 
John Hutchinson
1
 
1
Royal Veterinary College
 
2
University College London
 
3
Katholieke Universiteit Leuven
Terrestrial animals need to walk and run but also lie prone to rest and then stand up. The sit-to-stand (STS) transition likely imposes biomechanical constraints on limb design because it involves near-maximal excursions of some limb joints. Birds, a diverse lineage of bipedal animals with exceptional locomotor agility, provide a valuable opportunity to study STS biomechanics and the impact of body size on performance. However, experimental investigation is typically limited in revealing fundamental mechanisms. Using computational biomechanical models and predictive simulations, we can explore the questions on STS performance criteria, muscle-tendon dynamics, and body size influence in a detailed and mechanistic way. In this study, we used a combination of a 2D simplified model and a 3D high-fidelity musculoskeletal model to evaluate STS performance criteria (e.g., minimisation of effort) and estimate muscle functions in two birds of different sizes—the emu (Dromaius novaehollandiae) and the common pheasant (Phasianus colchicus). Our study provides insights into the control strategies used by birds during the STS transition and suggests the influence of anatomical and functional traits on STS performance. These findings enhance our understanding of constraints on muscle structure in extant animals and offer implications for reconstructing musculoskeletal function in extinct species. 
Pteraichnites as a tool for understanding pterosaur palaeoecology and evolution
 
Robert S. H. Smyth
 
1
University of Leicester
The Upper Jurassic (Oxfordian-Tithonian) deposits of the western USA form one of the world’s most extensively sampled Mesozoic sequences, yet skeletal material of pterosaurs is exceptionally rare. Despite a poor skeletal record, the region produces abundant pterosaur tracks, or pteraichnites. These tracks have significantly improved our understanding of pterosaur terrestrial locomotion, but their ecological and evolutionary implications remain largely unexplored. 

Here, extensive photogrammetric documentation of tracks has revealed a robust correlation between track morphology and pterosaur autopodial anatomy. Using both multivariate analyses and traditional diagnostic methodologies, tracks can be referred to specific pterosaur clades. Pteraichnites across multiple localities in the western USA represent ctenochasmatoid trackmakers. These ground-based feeders frequented intertidal flats surrounding the Sundance Sea. Trackways reflect specific behaviors, such as persistent walking parallel to the palaeoshoreline as well as foot-propelled swimming, an unusual locomotory mode that cannot be confidently inferred from skeletal morphology alone.  

The broad geographic and temporal distribution of ctenochasmatoid tracks demonstrates their early pervasiveness within marginal marine environments during the early Late Jurassic, much earlier than indicated by the body fossil record. Integrating pteraichnites into our understanding of the pterosaur fossil record holds great potential for enhancing our knowledge of pterosaur palaeobiogeography, evolution, and behaviour.
Rhamphorhynchus: a model for ontogenetic niche partitioning in pterosaurs?
 
David Unwin
 
1
University of Leicester
 
2
University of Birmingham
 
3
University of Lincoln
Ontogenetic niche partitioning (ONP) has recently been proposed for several pterosaurs, primarily on the basis of size distributions that, while suggestive, are not conclusive. Resolving this question is important as ONP has potentially profound implications for the taxonomy, systematics, ecology and evolutionary history of pterosaurs. This study focused on Rhamphorhynchus muensteri, utilised a large data set (130+ individuals) that represent an almost complete growth sequence and aimed to identify putative ontogenetic niches using multiple independent data sets: comparative morphology, morphometrics and tooth microwear. Three distinct ontogenetic niches were identified: small, highly immature, flight capable invertivores (wingspan 0.3-0.4 m; <1 year old); medium-sized aerial piscivores (wingspan 0.75-1.25 m; ~2 to 7 years old); and large, osteologically mature individuals (wingspans 1.25-1.9 m; >7 years old) that seemingly represent an extension of aerial piscivory to include prey of relatively large size. Key evidence such as tooth microwear, which directly reflects changes in prey preferences, skull shape and wing-configuration are strongly correlated, permitting a high degree of confidence in the identification of ONP in Rhamphorhynchus. This pterosaur could thus be of great utility for assessing ONP in other taxa and a preliminary analysis suggests that this phenomenon is widespread in pterosaurs.
Poster
Skull anatomy and paleoneurology of a new specimen of the von Huene’s gomphodont cynodont Traversodon stahleckeri (Middle-Late Triassic of Brazil)
 
Leonardo Kerber
 
1
Centro de Apoio à Pesquisa Paleontológica da Quarta Colônia/Universidade Federal de Santa Maria

Traversodontidae, a clade of gomphodont cynodonts, thrived during the Middle and Late Triassic, exhibiting a widespread distribution. Traversodon stahlekeri stands out as one of the earliest-known traversodontids. Discovered by Friedrich von Huene in 1936, the species is based on few remains found in the Chiniquá region, Dinodontosaurus AZ, Ladinian/early Carnian (Brazil). In more recent research, a new specimen (ULBRA PVT-049) was unearthed at the Bortolin Site (Dinodontosaurus AZ), offering invaluable insights into the skull anatomy and paleoneurology of the taxon. This discovery enabled the identification of previously unknown phylogenetic characters, enhancing our understanding of the species' evolutionary history. Additionally, the endocranial anatomy of T. stahleckeri was examined for the first time. Notably, the reconstruction of the cranial endocast revealed paleoneurological features consistent with non-gonfodontosuchine traversodontids, including the presence of an unossified zone and a pineal body. However, distinctively, the parietal foramen was closed in this specimen. The presence/absence of the parietal foramen in some traversodontids has been linked to ontogeny, with older individuals losing it while retaining the pineal body. These recent findings offer valuable contributions to understanding the evolutionary history and cranial characteristics of T. stahleckeri, shedding light on the diversity and adaptations of traversodontids.

Surely long wings have more feathers? Numbers of primary and secondary flight feathers reflect under-lying skeletal size but only in some orders of birds
 
D. Charles Deeming
 
1
University of Lincoln
 
2
University of Manchester
Bird wings vary in size and morphology in terms of both size and number of feathers and the underlying skeletal anatomy. The number of primary remiges does not seem to vary much between bird species but, by contrast, the number of secondary remiges ranges between 6–40 depending on bird size. Given that the primaries are attached to the manus and the secondaries are attached to the ulna, it was predicted that as bone lengths increased then feather count would increase. Data were collected for 251 species from 25 different orders and phylogenetically controlled analysis explored the allometry between feather count and bone size. Number of primaries did not vary with manus size but the number of secondaries increased with ulna length, but only in some orders. For example, in Gruiformes, the number of secondary feathers increased concomittantly with ulna length but in the Passeriformes almost all species had nine secondary remiges. It is unclear why birds with an ulna length of 70 mm can have between 9 and 24 secondaries. Further research is needed to explore size dependent variation in the breadth of the feather vane and its ability to withstand aerodynamic forces generated during a wing beat.
Surely long wings have more feathers? Numbers of primary and secondary flight feathers reflect under-lying skeletal size but only in some orders of birds
 
D Charles Deeming
 
1
Department of Life Sciences, School of Life and Environmental Sciences, University of Lincoln,
 
2
School of Biological Sciences, Faculty of Biology, Medicine & Health, University of Manchester

Bird wings vary in size and morphology in terms of both size and number of feathers and the underlying skeletal anatomy. The number of primary remiges does not seem to vary much between bird species but, by contrast, the number of secondary remiges ranges between 6–40 depending on bird size. Given that the primaries are attached to the manus and the secondaries are attached to the ulna, it was predicted that as bone lengths increased then feather count would increase. Data were collected for 251 species from 25 different orders and phylogenetically controlled analysis explored the allometry between feather count and bone size. Number of primaries did not vary with manus size but the number of secondaries increased with ulna length, but only in some orders. For example, in Gruiformes, the number of secondary feathers increased concomittantly with ulna length but in the Passeriformes almost all species had nine secondary remiges. It is unclear why birds with an ulna length of 70 mm can have between 9 and 24 secondaries. Further research is needed to explore size dependent variation in the breadth of the feather vane and its ability to withstand aerodynamic forces generated during a wing beat.

Platform presentation
Take another bite: new in vivo and estimated measurments of bite force demonstrate exceptionally large bite forces in parrots
 
Shannon L. Harrison
 
1
University of Lincoln
 
2
CNRS
Bite force, which in part determines the diet of an organism, is a function of the force exerted by contraction of the jaw musculature, applied via the jaw skeleton. Bite force has been determined in a range of vertebrate taxa using direct measurements using force transducers, or by calculation from skull morphology or jaw musculature. Bite force in birds has received little attention and values for parrots, anecdotally renown for strong bites, are rare. Bite force estimates for nineteen parrot species of differing sizes were calculated using a novel method that used areas of jaw muscles measured in situ and their masses. Bite forces were also separately recorded in vivo using force transducers, allowing for validation of the dissection-based models. There was a positive allometric relationship for bite force against body mass (measured slope of 0.95 vs an isometric prediction of 0.66) and against skull mass (0.83 vs 0.66). Macaws (Ara sp.) had the strongest bite recorded to date for a bird (539 N). Calculated values for bite force were not statistically different from measured values taken from birds. These results have implications for how parrots process food items and how bite forces are estimated in other taxa using morphology of the jaw musculature.
Poster
The Biomechanical Constraints on Hopping in Giant Kangaroo Hindlimbs
 
Megan Jones
 
1
University of Manchester

Several Pleistocene kangaroo species greatly exceeded the size of the largest kangaroos alive today. With extant large kangaroos already experiencing unusually high stresses in their hindlimbs while hopping, the size of these extinct megafaunal kangaroos has prompted the question: were they able to hop at all? At what body size is a kangaroo too big to feasibly hop? Previous attempts to answer this question have mainly focussed on extrapolating the safety factors of the hindlimb tendons. Here, we use biomechanical calculations to test the assumptions of these studies, by investigating the strength of the bones, muscles, and tendons of the giant kangaroo hindlimb, and testing which is most likely to limit the hopping ability of these species. We also attempt to minimise the extrapolation of scaling patterns beyond extant data, instead referring to fossil measurements wherever possible. We found that the bones and muscles of the hindlimb were likely capable of supporting hopping in giant kangaroos. Meanwhile, the strength of the tendons was indeed the most likely limiting factor, supporting the assumptions of prior studies.

The Congo Basin's Mysterious Hero: An investigtion into vertebral mobility and the impact of tubercles in Scutisorex.
 
Charles Bates
 
1
University of Manchester
 
2
Field Museum of Natural History: Chicago

The genus Scutisorex, also known as the Hero Shrew, possesses a unique vertebral morphology; The Transverse processes of its lumbar vertebrae, as well as some of its thoracic vertebrae, are dorsoventrally expanded and covered in numerous tubercles that project along the craniocaudal plane. Despite detailed documentation of Scutisorex’s skeletal and muscular anatomy (at least with regards to the first found species, S. somereni), as well as analyses of trabecular bone and research into Scutisorex's biomechanical properties, the biological function of this extreme morphology remains unknown.


This study attempts to rectify this gap in research through ‘AutoBend’, a novel program that offers an automated approach to estimating the mobility of vertebral joints. The mobility of Scutisorex’s vertebral column is compared to those of Shrew’s with more typical Soricid morphology, and the impact of Scutisorex’s tubercles on mobility is assessed. The two key hypotheses tested are as follows; (1) That vertebral range of motion is lower in Scutisorex than in more typical Soricids and lower in the apparently more derived S. somereni than the apparently less derived S. thori, and (2) that in both species of Scutisorex, joints with higher tubercle counts will be less mobile.

The Evolution of Golden Moles and Tenrecs (Afrotheria, Mammalia)
 
Robert Asher
 
1
University of Cambridge

We undertook a phylogenetic analysis of genetic and anatomical data focusing on golden moles (Chrysochloridae) and tenrecs (Tenrecidae). Our results support the now well-resolved topology for extant tenrecids, and the paraphyly of "Chrysochlorinae" and the genera Chrysochloris and Chlorotalpa as traditionally used. The oldest divergence within crown Chrysochloridae is likely the node separating Eremitalpa-Huetia or Eremitalpa alone from the remaining species. A Chrysochloris-Cryptochloris root appears most frequently under equally-weighted parsimony, or with few or no sampled tenrecids, suggesting it is artefactual. The tropical genus Huetia is among the most widely distributed and anatomically polymorphic in our sample. Eremitalpa and Huetia have a relatively unspecialized hyoid apparatus and short angular process of the dentary. These elements in Huetia show a particular resemblance to those of the Namibian fossil Namachloris, which we reconstruct as a stem chrysochlorid. Crown chrysochlorids are geologically younger than crown tenrecids, and likely diversified in the Miocene around the same time as the tenrecid genus Microgale. Fossils of both groups from Eocliff in Namibia are probably late Eocene to early Miocene in age.

Platform presentation
The fish assemblage of the Lower Cretaceous (upper Barremian–lower Aptian) Arrifes section (Algarve Basin, Southern Portugal)
 
Hélder J.R. Pereira
 
1
CITEUC, Centre for Earth and Space Research of the University of Coimbra, Faculty of Sciences and Technology, Earth Sciences Department, University of Coimbra - Pólo II, Rua Sílvio Lima, 3030-790 Coimbra, Portugal
 
2
CIMA, Centre of Marine and Environmental Research\ARNET - Infrastructure Network in Aquatic Research, University of Algarve, Campus de Gambelas, 8000-139 Faro, Portugal
 
3
School of the Environment, Geography and Geosciences, University of Portsmouth, Burnaby Building, Burnaby Road, Portsmouth, P01 3QL, UK
 
4
Grupo de Investigación PaleoIbérica, Universidad de Alcalá, 28805 Alcalá de Henares, Madrid, Spain
The Arrifes coastal section – which is located approximately 2 km west of Albufeira (Central Algarve) – provides exposures of a sequence of late Barremian–early Aptian age. Bulk samples totalling 500 kg were collected from several horizons and were processed for the recovery of microvertebrate remains. The study and description of the collected material have permitted the identification of an unexpectedly rich and diverse vertebrate fauna.
The fish assemblage comprises both chondrichthyans (Carcharhiniformes, Heterodontiformes, Lamniformes, and Rajiformes) and osteichthyans (Amiiformes, Elopiformes, Lepisosteiformes, Ionoscopiformes, Pycnodontiformes) and is represented mainly by fragmentary and isolated material (fragments of dental plates, teeth, ganoid scales, vertebrae, thorns and dermal denticles).
The fish assemblage recorded in the Arrifes section corresponds to a mixture of freshwater, euryhaline and marine taxa. Some of these taxa are recorded for the first time in the Lower Cretaceous of Portugal. The fish remains are associated with benthic foraminifera, ostracods and other marine invertebrates but also with charophytes, numerous plant remains and insect coprolites, and disarticulated non-marine vertebrate remains (lissamphibians, lepidosaurs, turtles, crocodyliforms and dinosaurs).
The new data presented here have considerable paleoenvironmental implications and provide additional insight into the environment of deposition and palaeoecology of the central part of the Algarve Basin during the Early Cretaceous.
The influence of jaw muscle architecture on mandibular disparity in Lepidosauria
 
Antonio Ballell
 
1
University of Bristol
 
2
Field Museum of Natural History
 
3
UMR7179 CNRS/MNHN

The interplay between skull morphology and architecture of jaw muscles remains understudied, despite its importance in identifying functional and developmental constraints shaping head evolution. Combining data on muscular and skeletal anatomy in a phylogenetic context can provide a clearer picture of the integration of the musculoskeletal system and the functional and ecological implications of morphological change. Lepidosaurs show outstanding variation in skull anatomy and jaw adductor configuration, as well as a wide range of dietary habits, representing an ideal study case to investigate the relationship between osteology, myology and ecology. Here, we quantify mandibular disparity across Lepidosauria by applying 3D geometric morphometrics in a sample of over 80 species. The effect and covariation of muscular anatomy on mandibular shape is tested using phylogenetic comparative methods and different muscular parameters (muscle mass, PCSA) obtained from dissected specimens. Finally, we test the relationships between diet, mandibular shape and muscular anatomy. Our results show that mandibular shape is partly explained by phylogenetic relatedness, allometry and diet. Muscle architecture covaries with mandibular morphology, suggesting that the jaw and associated muscles have evolved as an integrated system in Lepidosauria, facilitating the acquisition of the remarkable ecological diversity of the clade.

The Lincoln Plesiosaurs
 
Richard Forrest
 
1
plesiosaur.com

The Collection at Lincoln has on display a fine specimen of a plesiosaur. It was found at the beginning of the last century in a brick pit within the city at a site now occupied by a primary school, who use it as their logo. It was on display during the 1960s but was  forgotten until it was rediscovered in the museum stores in the late 1990s. It has been identified as a member of the Microclididae from the Pliensbachian Lias and is one of the most complete pleiosaur  specimens from this period. It is partly in a limestone nodue which gives some eviedence for a hstory of predation by a large, torsion-feeding predator.


Another substantially complete plesiosaur, unfortunately (and typically!) missing a skull  in the museum collection is not on display. It is part of a collection passed on from Grantham Museum in the early 20s when they were no longer able to store their geological material. It has not be the subject of any research, and information on provenance is limited. It was found in the early part of the 20th century, and fortunately photographed in situ at the time using a large format camera. The glass plates have deteriorated over time but could still be scanned to give reasonably good images. 


It appears to be from the Middle Lias, and is possibly a rhomaleosaurid plesiosaur.

The Untold Story of the Carnegie Diplodocus
 
Mike Taylor
 
1
University of Bristol
 
2
Carnegie Museum of Natural History
 
3
Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences
 
4
Utah Field House of Natural History
 
5
University of Colorado Museum
The sauropod dinosaur Diplodocus is best known from the iconic Carnegie specimen, casts of which were sent around the world in the early 1900s. The original skeleton was mounted in 1907, but its composition was complex: it contained real bone from four individuals, with casts and sculptures from six further specimens — some of which were from distantly related camarsaurids. Cast/sculpted material includes the skull, forelimbs and forefeet.

Published estimates of the skeleton's length have varied wildly: new measurements establish it at 26.1m.

In 1957, a last cast was made, in concrete, by the Utah Field House in Vernal, Utah. It stood outside the museum for three decades. The molds, weighing three tons, were shipped to Rocky Rount, North Carolina, with the intention of casting another outdoor Diplodocus, but work eventually ground to a halt. The molds were probably lost or destroyed around 1965.

However, in 1989, new molds were made from the concrete cast. Second-generation casts have been made from these, and now inhabit Japan, Canada and several locations in Florida, as well as Vernal. Elements cast from these new molds have also been incorporated into other mounts, such as the iconic rearing Barosaurus in the AMNH atrium.
Thoracic cage morphology coadapts with aerobic capacity in artificially selected High Runner mice
 
Elizabeth Webb
 
1
University of Manchester
 
2
University of California, Riverside
Cursoriality, fast and sustained running, is a specialized behavior that has evolved numerous times in mammals. However, it is challenging to disentangle skeletal adaptations for cursoriality from other potentially correlated factors. The High Runner (HR) project is an experiment in which mice were selected based on voluntary wheel running, resulting in four replicate lines that run three times further than four control lines. These mice have myriad cursorial adaptations, including increased endurance and maximal oxygen consumption during forced exercise (VO2max). However, the role of thoracic morphology in facilitating increased VO2max of HR lines is unclear. Here, we examine thoracic cage morphology in HR mice, and test the hypothesis of increased rib cage volume relative to controls. We postulate that ventilatory capacity may be increased via increased thoracic count or changing rib shape. Thoracic count and rib shape was measured using 3D geometric morphometrics and compared between HR and control lines. We find that some replicate HR lines have increased thoracic count, but other lines have modified rib shape to increase rib curvature or length. Therefore, we find varying adaptive responses in thoracic cage morphology to similar selection pressures, suggesting many-to-one form-function mapping in mammalian ventilation.
Poster
Tracing archosauromorph origins through space, time, and climate in the TARDIS
 
*
Joseph Flannery-Sutherland
 
1
University of Bristol

The diversification of archosauromorph reptiles from the Late Permian to Late Triassic is a classic example of an adaptive radiation. It has received significant attention from phylogenetic, morphological and ecological perspectives, but its spatial signature is understudied. I reconstruct the geographic origins of early archosauromorphs using a taxonomically updated, time-calibrated super tree. I then couple landscape connectivity analysis and high-resolution reconstructions of deep time climate and topography in a novel workflow (TARDIS – traversal and routes of dispersal in spacetime) to infer the phylogeographic structure of their radiation across the ecologically anachronous stage presented by Pangaea. Finally, I quantify their rates and routes of dispersal and rates of climate adaptation to examine the biogeographic constraints on their early evolutionary success. Preliminary results highlight that the deepest archosauromorph divergences took place in European Pangaea but later cladogenetic events were geographically disparate and frequently involved trans-equatorial dispersals. This indicates that that extreme climates across the supercontinent were not as robust biogeographic barriers as previously suspected and demonstrates the role that landscape connectivity analysis can play in reconstructing the spatial dynamics of evolutionary radiations.

Two new Kimmerosaurus specimens expand geographic range and morphological understanding of the genus
 
Aubrey Roberts
 
1
Natural History Museum, University of Oslo
 
2
University of Southampton
 
3
The Etches Collection
 
4
London Natural History Museum

Cryptoclidid plesiosaurs were widely distributed across the Northern hemisphere during the Late Jurassic, displaying regional endemism at a species level, with few genera shared between regions. In this study, we present two new specimens that offer new material from Kimmerosaurus, as well as the first recorded presence of this genus from the Boreal Region (Svalbard). The two new specimens are PMO 212.662 from the Slottsmøya Formation of Svalbard (Norway) and K2134 from the Kimmeridge Clay Formation (UK - Etches collection). K2134 includes a disarticulated partial skull and four cervical vertebrae. PMO 212.662 includes a partial skull with partially articulated axial and appendicular elements. Computed tomography of K2134 provides amazing imagery of the specimen – significantly adding details on the rostrum, palate, and cheek region for Kimmerosaurus langhami. K2134 is largely similar to the holotype of K. langhami, with some differences in the atlas-axis and braincase. PMO 212.662 shares the unique Kimmerosaurus trait of a lack of a sagittal crest, as well as aspects of braincase morphology. In addition, this specimen provides previously unknown insights into the morphology of the posterior cervical and dorsal axial skeleton. Phylogenetic analysis supports the close relationship of these two specimens with Kimmerosaurus.

Understanding the mechanisms of polyphyodonty: insights gained from tooth replacement in fish
 
Sally Collins
 
1
Birkbeck, University of London
 
2
Natural History Museum, London

Most jawed vertebrates exhibit lifelong tooth replacement (polyphyodonty), and there is a great drive to understand its developmental basis. Here, surface feature observations and X-ray micro-CT virtual sections are used to identify tooth replacement mechanisms in fossil and modern fish. Tooth replacement requires a ‘dental lamina’, an epithelial connection which enables only one tooth to be replaced by one successor, at any one time, and provides the putative stems cells required for long-term tooth renewal. However, ‘one-for-one’ replacement is not present in the crushing dentitions of an extinct group of fishes, the pycnodonts. Instead, tooth positioning suggests an opportunistic, gap-filling addition, where teeth fill any available space e.g. arising from tooth damage/loss. Contrastingly, in the modern fish specimens, tooth replacement mechanisms are recognisable, although seabream show unusual change in tooth size, shape, and positioning, over one tooth generation. Pycnodont, seabream and other crushing dentitions exhibit a close-packed, near-tessellating patterning. I hypothesise that in pycnodonts, gap-filling occurred by the oral epithelium retaining odontogenic potential throughout life, possibly facilitated by stem cells that generate taste buds. I also hypothesise that tooth patterning in crushing dentitions is an adaptive phenotypic response to mechanical strain at the crushing surface, a known phenomenon in cichlids.

Platform presentation
Using your head – cranial steering in pterosaurs
 
Donald Henderson
 
1
Royal Tyrrell Museum of Palaeontology

The vast majority of pterosaurs are characterized by large, elongate skulls. Projecting out in front of the body, these large heads must have had an aerodynamic effect. The working hypothesis of the present study is that these oversize heads were used to control the left-right motions of the body during flight. Using digital models of six, long-tailed “rhamphorhyncoids” and six, short-tailed pterodactlyoids, the turning moments associated with the head+neck showed an isometric correspondence with the rotational inertia of the whole body about a vertical axis in both groups.  Turning moments come from calculating the lateral area of the head (plus any crests) and determining the associated lift coefficient as a function of flight speed. Rotational inertias were calculated from the three-dimensional mass distribution of the axial body, the limbs and the flight membranes. Substantial tail fins at the end of the tail are only known from specimens of Rhamphorhynchus muensteri. Unlike other pterosaurs, the head moments of Rhamphorhynchus lagged behind their rotational inertias. However, the tail fins provide additional turning moments in Rhamphorhynchus, and suggest a flight style different from other tailed pterosaurs.

Poster
Variation in pedal morphology of kangaroos suggests different mechanisms drive digit reduction in hopping and ‘giant’ short-faced lineages
 
George Watts
 
1
University of Bristol
Locomotory styles of extant kangaroos (Macropodoidea) include hopping, walking, climbing, and bounding; the extinct giant short-faced kangaroos (Sthenurinae) are proposed to employ bipedal striding. The pedal morphology of extant kangaroos exhibits variance in the relative robusticity of the fifth and fourth digits (other digits are lost or highly reduced). The role of the smaller fifth digit in weight bearing and locomotion remains unknown, as well as the reasons for its loss in Plio-Pleistocene sthenurines which are monodactyl. Here we employ linear measurements of fourth and fifth metatarsals from 86 macropod individuals (including two Miocene sthenurines that which retain digit five), thus establishing patterns of variation in fifth metatarsal robusticity with the view to understand sthenurine digit loss. Morphometric analysis showed that within the extant subfamily Macropodinae fifth metatarsal robusticity depends on the length of the fourth metatarsal: elongate feet have thinner fifth metatarsals and short feet more robust ones. The large extinct macropodines Protemnodon and Congruus have short feet and robust fifth digits. The sthenurines do not conform to this macropodine pattern of digit reduction, retaining a robust fifth digit with an elongated fourth one. Thus the reasons and mechanisms of digit loss in Plio-Pleistocene sthenurines remain obscure.
Platform presentation
WIP - Integrating form and function in a multi-variate phylogenetic regression framework.
 
Manabu Sakamoto
 
1
University of Lincoln
TBC